Performance Max During the Slow Season: Should You Lower Target ROAS or Switch to Maximise Conversions?
A question came up on an Ecommerce community I’m part of that I suspect a fair few of you are quietly living through right now. Someone had a Performance Max campaign running on a specific group of products. Through the
A question came up on an Ecommerce community I’m part of that I suspect a fair few of you are quietly living through right now.
Someone had a Performance Max campaign running on a specific group of products. Through the high season it converted without a problem. Then the slower season arrived, the campaign stopped spending, stopped converting, and now it brings in only a handful of sales a week. Meanwhile those same products keep selling through other outlets, so demand has clearly not vanished entirely. It felt to them as though Performance Max had simply stopped showing the products, as if the campaign had never been trained for a slower season.
The setup was Maximise Conversion Value with a Target ROAS of 300%. The question was whether to switch to Maximise Conversions, or lower the Target ROAS instead. And, because the season will keep sliding until it picks up again next year, whether making changes now would throw Performance Max off.
Here is how I would think it through.
Your Campaign Is Probably Not Broken
My honest view is that it is possible, and in fact likely, that Performance Max stopped spending because people stopped searching.
It is the down season. If fewer people are searching, there are fewer people to put ads in front of. That is the whole story. A drop in spend and conversions in Performance Max during a down season is not, in and of itself, evidence that anything is wrong with your campaign.
This matters more than it sounds, because the instinct when a campaign goes quiet is to assume the algorithm has broken, or that the campaign has somehow forgotten how to work. Performance Max has not lost the plot. It is bidding into an auction that has fewer people in it.
The other outlets still selling those products are not the counter-argument they appear to be. Selling a few units through a marketplace, a wholesale relationship, or repeat customers who already know you is a very different thing from a stranger typing your product into Google at nine o'clock on a Tuesday night. Those channels reach people who are already in your orbit. Paid search needs fresh demand to exist before it can capture it.
Check the Demand Before You Touch Anything
Before you change a single setting, the job is to confirm what you are looking at.
The comparison that answers the question is not this month versus last month. Of course this month looks worse, that is what a season is. The comparison you want is this period against the same period last year, and ideally the year before that. If your quiet months looked like this last year too, you are on your normal seasonal curve and there is nothing to fix.
Then look at impressions and impression share alongside spend. If impressions have fallen while your impression share has held steady or even improved, that is a demand story. The auction shrank, and you are still winning your usual slice of it. If impressions have fallen while impression share collapsed, that is a different conversation and worth investigating properly.
Also worth a look: whether your products are still approved and in stock in Merchant Centre, and whether anything else changed at the same time the numbers fell. Seasonality is the most likely explanation, but it is not the only one, and five minutes of checking saves you from optimising a campaign that has a feed problem.
Why Switching Bid Strategy Is Rarely the First Move
The question posed was Maximise Conversions or Target ROAS. I would reframe it slightly, because a bid strategy swap is a bigger, blunter intervention than most people realise, and it does not address the actual constraint.
Your campaign is on Maximise Conversion Value with a target attached. If that target is what is holding spend back, the thing to adjust is the target, not the whole strategy. Swapping to a different strategy entirely changes what the campaign is optimising towards, and you will be judging the results against a quiet season where the data is thin anyway. You end up with two variables moving at once and no clean way to read which one caused what.
So the real decision is narrower and more useful: is your Target ROAS the constraint, and are you genuinely willing to trade profitability for volume right now?
The Quiet Season Is the Cheap Season to Test
Here is the part I would prioritise, and it is the part most people skip.
Low season is a good time to run A/B tests. Ad creative, pricing, product titles, images, any of it. The reason is simple economics. When you test during your busiest months, the lower performing side of the test costs you real money in lost sales at exactly the moment those sales are worth the most. When you test during the quiet season, that same losing variant costs you very little, because there was not much on the table to lose in the first place.
That makes the down season the cheapest window in your year to learn something. Test your product titles. Test your imagery. Test pricing. Test the creative you have been meaning to try but never dared to run in November.
The pay-off is not this month's revenue. The pay-off is walking into your next high season with titles, images and creative you have actually validated, rather than the ones you assumed were fine.
When Lowering or Removing Target ROAS Is Justified
Now, adjusting targets and goals. My position is to do it only if you really need to.
If conversion volume has dropped so far that you simply need to stimulate more conversions, and you are comfortable risking lower profitability in order to do that, then a Target ROAS drop during low season is worth considering. That is a real trade and you should make it with your eyes open, not by accident.
There is a second reason that is easy to overlook. If you want to run those A/B tests, and the tests require more conversion volume than you are currently receiving, then a lower target that buys you more data can be the thing that makes the testing possible at all. Testing on almost no conversions tells you nothing.
If conversion volumes drop really low during your low season, you might even consider removing your Target ROAS entirely, running Maximise Conversion Value coupled with tight budget control to manage performance instead.
That pairing is the important bit. Removing the target without tightening the budget is how people frighten themselves. The target was doing the work of capping your downside. Take it away and the budget has to do that job instead. Set a daily budget you are genuinely comfortable spending in a quiet month, and let the campaign work inside it.
Will All the Changes Throw Performance Max Off?
This was the reader's sharpest question, and it deserves a straight answer.
The risk is not that you make a change. The risk is that you make several changes in quick succession, none of them large enough to matter on their own, and then find you cannot tell what caused what. During a quiet season, with thin data, that confusion is much easier to fall into because every number wobbles.
So change things in a measured way. One meaningful change at a time. Move the target in a deliberate step rather than nudging it every few days. Then leave it alone long enough for the campaign to settle and for you to see enough conversions to form a real opinion. If you find yourself back in the settings the following morning because yesterday looked bad, that is the instinct to resist.
And remember that whatever you do for the low season is a low season decision. When demand returns, your targets should return with it.
Conclusion
A Performance Max campaign that stops spending and converting when your season turns down is usually reflecting reduced demand, not a broken campaign. Fewer people searching means fewer people to advertise to, and that alone explains most seasonal drops.
Before changing anything, confirm the story. Compare against the same period last year rather than last month, look at impressions alongside impression share, and rule out feed or approval problems.
Switching bid strategy is rarely the right first move. If Target ROAS is the constraint, adjust the target rather than replacing the entire strategy and muddying your read on the results.
Use the quiet season for A/B testing. Creative, pricing, titles and images can all be tested at a fraction of the cost, because the losing variant is not eating into your busiest trading months.
Lower the Target ROAS only if you genuinely need more conversion volume and accept the profitability trade, or if your tests need more data than you are currently receiving. If volumes fall very low, removing the target and running Maximise Conversion Value with tight budget control is a legitimate option, provided the budget is doing the job the target used to do.
Finally, change things deliberately. One meaningful adjustment at a time, given enough room to settle, beats a run of small nervous edits you can no longer untangle.
More Articles
All ArticlesGoogle Shopping Product Type: How To Optimise It With A Free AI Tool (2026)
When it comes to keyword targeting in Google Shopping Ads, after your product title, the single most important field in your entire Shopping feed is the product type. It is the second biggest lever you have for
How to Set Up Google Ads Conversion Tracking in Shopify: Easy Step-by-Step Guide (2026)
If you sell on Shopify and want to run Google Ads, conversion tracking is the first thing to sort out. Without it, Google has no idea which clicks turned into sales, and neither do you. I've run my Google Ads agency,